The element of garden design referred to as ‘plant size’ includes many facets, height being just one. Plant spread, density, and footprint are other factors of plant size that gardeners consider when selecting plants and designing their garden spaces. Giving consideration to the whole concept of plant size is critical when selecting plants and planning for a mixed perennial garden, such as Lurie Garden.
The garden designer, like the artist, has a toolbox of techniques and elements they use to create a beautiful scene. Learning about these elements increases appreciation of a garden’s design and, should you be inspired, guides you on how to create your own.
There are typically four elements when talking about plant size:
- Plant height is the measurement of the plant from the ground to the top-most portion of the plant at maturity.
- Plant spread is the maximum width of the plant as measured at its widest part from leaf tip to leaf tip at maturity.
- The density of a plant refers to the amount of open space within the plant’s stem, leaf, and flower growth. A good visual assessment of a plant’s density is to see how much background can be seen through the plant’s growth.
- A plant’s footprint refers to the amount of space on the ground, usually measured in square feet, that a mature plant will occupy.
Next to flower color, gardeners at all skill levels often focus on plant size as a factor when selecting plants and designing gardens. This focus on plant size is natural—size is an easily quantified characteristic, can be readily visualized, and represents a simple mechanism for plant classification.
Plant height can also be used by gardeners to arrange plants to either avoid or take advantage of the effects of shading by taller plants. When you view a garden, your eyes are naturally drawn to unique and interesting elements. Plant size is leveraged by the designer to move your eye through the garden. Watch where your eyes go when you look at the picture below. Where does your attention always end up?
Plant Height
Plant height, in landscape architecture terms, forms the foundation of the concept of vertical structure. The vertical structure of a garden draws attention to particular areas of or specific plants in the garden. Three primary plant heights are common in garden design: base plants, seasonal theme plants, and structural plants. Let’s discuss each layer, from shortest to tallest.
Base Plants
Base plants are low growing, short stature plants that effectively cover bare ground. This shortest group of plants (typically no taller than 30 cm) are the first line of defense against an invasion of weeds, occupying open soil spaces in the garden and excluding space for weeds. Base plants also help in preventing soil erosion in the garden and aid in soil moisture retention. This group of plants can comprise up to 50% of your garden.
In addition to helping in weed control and soil erosion, base plants are regularly used to create masses of solid color (monochromatic) plantings into which other seasonal theme and structural plants are planted. Think of base plants as the primary wall color of a room—covering lots of space, connecting all four walls of a room, and creating a platform onto which highlights can now be added.
Examples of base plants include: Carex pennsylvanica (Pennsylvania sedge), Sesleria autumnalis (moor grass), Ruellia humilis (wild petunia), Geum triflorum (prairie smoke), and Allium ‘Summer Beauty’. The latter three plants serve a dual purpose as base plants and seasonal theme plants.
Seasonal Theme Plants
Seasonal theme plants (typically no taller than 90 cm) work hand-in-hand with based plants to fill space in the garden, but add flowering interest throughout the growing seasons. Base plants set the stage for building a scene, seasonal theme plants can be complementary or contrasting beyond base plants that entice your eye to explore. Seasonal theme plants can occupy 30-40% of your garden space.
Year round planting design is a true four-season display, with various seasonal theme plants providing visual treats throughout the year. For example, in the early spring hybrid tulips (Tulipa cultivars) provide seasonal theme interest, which gives way to a late spring display of Zizia aurea (golden Alexander), which in-turn gives way to summer seasonal theme plantings of milkweeds (Asclepias tuberosa, A. incarnata), and so on through all seasons. This concept of a rolling bloom across multiple seasons combines the ideas of plant size with timing.
Structural Plants
Structural plants are the tall, standout plants of the garden (typically taller than 120 cm). This group of plants, often the tallest plants in the garden, bring distinctive interest and attention to specific areas of your garden. Structural plants should be used sparingly to prevent a visual sensory overload in your garden. This group of plants should represent only 5-15% of your garden.
Structural plants can be used to create consistent points of visual height interest across multiple seasons. For example, Amsonia hubrichtii (Arkansas blue star) blooming in early spring is, for that time, one of the tallest plants in the garden. Come summer, A. hubrichtii remains one of the tallest plants in the garden and, even though not flowering, provides a visual highlight with its soft-appearing foliage. In fall, this same species brings a bright golden yellow to the garden while still being one of the tallest plants in the garden.
Other examples of structural plants include: Panicum ‘Shenandoah’ (red switch grass), Echinacea pallida (pale coneflower), Echinacea ‘Virgin’ (virgin cone flower), and Rodgersia pinnata (featherleaf rodgersia).
Things to remember when considering the role of plant size in garden design:
- When experiencing a garden scene, be aware of your senses. For example, consider where your eyes go and what did the garden designer do to draw your attention there?
- When planning your garden, be aware of the full and mature height of the plants you have selected. A simple approach is to stage plants with tallest in back, moving to shortest in front.
- When buying plants for your garden, remember to think percent coverage and purchase accordingly. A good rule of thumb is that base plants should occupy up to 50% of the space, seasonal theme plants represent 30-40% of the space, while structural plants should occupy only 5-15% of your garden.
- Remember that each plant type and color family can be spread across multiple height layers. For example, plants in the base plant layers and seasonal theme plant layers can be the same or similar color families.
- Plant size is just one of many considerations for organizing garden designs. Starting with one basic element, such as plant size, is a great way to get to understand plants grow and how they will fair in your garden.
- Gardening is a relationship between you and your plants. Like all relationships listening to how your partner is responding to you is important and a very rewarding process!
- Do not be afraid to actively experiment in your garden. All gardeners kill plants…and it is ok! Gardening is always an experiment and there are always more plants.
Absolutely loved your commentary on garden design based on how plants grow in nature and it’s structural aspects. I recently attended a presentation by Claudia West, coauthor of “Planting in a Post-Wild World” which supports the concepts outlined in your article. I especially appreciate examples of plants mentioned in your article used in each layer of a plant design. And, I absolutely love Lurie Garden and visit each time I travel to Chicago.
Betty: Thank you for your comments. Thomas and Claudia’s book, “Planting in a Post-Wild World,” is a wonderful and timely addition to the conversation of modern, sustainable landscape architecture. I had the pleasure of co-presenting with both Claudia and Thomas at the 2015 American Society of Landscape Architects annual conference, with the two authors discussing the concept and application of their design principles complemented by input from me about managing designed plant communities on time-scales of decades in order to maintain their function and appearance.
Stay tuned to Lurie Garden’s future blogs for more commentary about elements of designed plant communities as they relate to the design of Lurie Garden.
A thoughtful discussion to guide designers in plant selection. The important concept of experimentation in plant selection is supported wonderfully by your affirmation that plants die and it’s ok.
Peggy: You are spot-on…experimentation in the garden should be encouraged. Thanks for the great comment!
Scott – this is a great article. Definitely a help for artfully placing the lovely plants from the Lurie Garden plant sale last Saturday!
Mary Beth: Thanks for the positive feedback! Stay tuned for future blogs about the other elements of plant size, as well as other garden design topics.
What a helpful article and photographs/drawings that illustrate your points AND give specific plant names. Thanks from a Southerner with family in Chicago! We’ll stay an extra day one trip to explore Lurie Garden.
Well thank you for the great comment. Please do come visit Lurie Garden and enjoy a beautiful day in the garden!
More people need to know information like this. When we bought our townhouse in 2003, on either side of the walkway to the front door were euonymus bushes. They were lovely, but too big for the area. (Personally I think they’re best suited for a natural border between property lines.) I eventually had them removed.
The owners who planted them had bought them small, maybe in 8 inch pots with the height and width of something “cute”. In-between the bushes were azaleas. They had become so dwarfed by the euonymus that they were hard to see.
Thanks for the great comment, Mary. Yes, too often people purchase a plant for their home landscape and do not consider that plants size, shape, or structure after 5, 10, or 20-years of growth. When installing a landscape, you must think not only about today but also about the long-term future of those plants in their places.
hello
Very informative article that help everyone.Every visitor look that type of information.i glad to you for getting a full of instruction form here.i hope your all article like that and wish you all the best for the next
A well written and really helpful article. Many thanks for posting this. All the best, David.
Thank you for some other informative blog. Where else could I get that type of information written in such an ideal means? I have a mission that I’m just now working on, and I have been at the look out for such information.
Great article! Thank you for a really important and informative blog. I was just looking for this type of articles. I recently open a landscaping company in Kent, UK. We are focused on landscaping but we didn’t thought of garden design as an specific service we can provide. Many thanks for posting this, and I will update you on how we did with this new option. Carlo